Daat Emet
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
Daat Emet
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
  • Torah, Science & Ethics
    • Pamphlets
    • Scientific Errors in Torah
    • Religion & Ethics
    • Mitzvahs
    • Religion Caught in Its Own Net
  • Torah & Talmud
    • Weekly Portion
    • Torah Text
    • Talmud Issues
    • Daily Peppers
  • Questions & Answers
  • Who We Are
    • About Daat Emet
    • Our Supporters
    • Support Us
  • English
    • עברית (Hebrew)
    • Русский (Russian)
    • Yiddish
    • Français (French)
One who thought he heard the braying of a donkey but really heard a shofar has not fulfilled his obligation
Home » Daily Peppers
Yaron Yadan 01/11/2010
One who thought he heard the braying of a donkey but really heard a shofar has not fulfilled his obligation

According to one of the sages, Rava, religious law does not require intention for the fulfillment of a commandment. It is enough, technically, to perform the commandment. Therefore one who takes a shofar on Rosh Hashanah and begins to blow it as a musical instrument, not for the purposes of fulfilling the commandment, is considered to have fulfilled the commandment to blow the shofar, for the sages stated “commandments do not require intention.” The scholars ask: If one does not have to be aware to fulfill a commandment, why was it ruled that a person who is walking past a synagogue on Rosh Hashanah and suddenly hears the sound of a shofar must intend to fulfill the commandment of hearing the blowing of the shofar? Answer: The requirement that he must intend to fulfill the commandment means that he must consciously identify the sound as that of a shofar and not as that of something else, but if he thought he heard the sound of something else, for example the sound of a donkey, did not fulfill the commandment even if in practice he did hear the sound of a shofar. The scholars went on to ask: If one does not have to be aware that he is fulfilling a commandment, why was it ruled that one who blows the shofar must have intention? The one who blows obviously knows that he is blowing the shofar, yet he was required to intend to and be aware that he is fulfilling a commandment. Answer: There is no real need for the one blowing the shofar to intend his notes to fulfill the commandment, but he must be careful to blow the halachically required notes with their proper length.
(Babylonian Talmud, Tractate Rosh Hashanah 28b)

About the Author

ירון ידען View all posts by Yaron Yadan

ירון ידען (נולד בטבריה ב-8 בדצמבר 1961) הוא פעיל חברתי ומייסד ארגון "דעת אמת" העומד בראש מפלגת אור.

Additional Peppers
Does the fox have venom in its claws?

Does the fox have venom in its claws?

Sages are permitted to marry a woman for a single day and then to divorce her

Sages are permitted to marry a woman for a single day and then to divorce her

Two mice, one bearing matzah and the other chametz, enter different houses

Two mice, one bearing matzah and the other chametz, enter different houses

Healing infants, particularly after circumcision

Healing infants, particularly after circumcision

Is a red heifer which sprouts a white hair on its tail and another on its head valid or invalid?

Is a red heifer which sprouts a white hair on its tail and another on its head valid or invalid?

One who steals an ox, cuts off its horns, and then sells it

One who steals an ox, cuts off its horns, and then sells it

One may speak ill of the dead

One may speak ill of the dead

© 2016 כל הזכויות שמורות לדעת אמת.
Skip to content
Open toolbar Accessibility Tools

Accessibility Tools

  • Increase TextIncrease Text
  • Decrease TextDecrease Text
  • GrayscaleGrayscale
  • High ContrastHigh Contrast
  • Negative ContrastNegative Contrast
  • Light BackgroundLight Background
  • Links UnderlineLinks Underline
  • Readable FontReadable Font
  • Reset Reset